When asked whether he would put his name next to the
controversial voter ID legislation passed by the General Assembly that would
require voters without identification to cast provisional ballots, Gov.
McDonnell made no signs of committing one way or the other on Sunday.
Legislators reasonably rejected the governor’s proposed
amendment earlier in April that would have required members of the electoral
board to compare the signature in a voter’s registration file with the
signature on a provisional ballot to confirm the identity of the voter. This
scheme would have undoubtedly led to a host of other problems in the voter
confirmation process. Some have suggested that the entire point of the McDonnell
amendment was to eliminate the bill.[1]
As critics of the voter ID bill have contended, the
legislation runs the risk of making it more difficult for traditionally
democratic blocs of voters to vote, groups such as minorities, the elderly, and
students. Indeed, the fact that voter ID bills have been passed in other “red”
states this year makes it appear like the legislation is part of a concerted
effort by the Republican Party to disqualify a sizable chunk of Democratic
Party voters from the voting process before elections take place this year. [2]
Advocates of the bill have argued that preventing voter
fraud was the primary impetus behind the legislation.
However, until quite
recently, charges of voter fraud hadn’t been given out or suspected in the commonwealth.[3]
So if proponents of the voter ID legislation wish to keep this feather in their
cap, it would be a rare example of ante hoc legislation and a push for greater
government red-tape before any problems were realized.
If Gov. McDonnell has effectively issued this bill’s death
warrant, it would be an admission by the governor that the legislation is
unnecessary and political poison. But I’m sure Virginia’s GOP is already
strategizing about how to pass the bill again next year, and this time, signed
into law.
[1] http://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/mcdonnells-wise-move-on-virginias-voter-id-bill/2012/04/12/gIQAnyenDT_story.html
[2] http://www.chron.com/news/politics/article/DOJ-asks-for-trial-delay-in-Texas-Voter-ID-case-3507472.php
[3] http://www2.timesdispatch.com/news/2012/apr/22/tdmain01-va-investigates-voter-fraud-ar-1859666/
No comments:
Post a Comment