Sunday, June 17, 2012

Marshall decries appointment of Virginia’s first openly gay judge, surprise, surprise


Del. Robert G. Marshall (R-Prince William) has become synonymous with bigoted rhetoric[1], and his latest lambast of Gov. Bob McDonnell on Friday over the governor’s support for the appointment of Tracy Thorne-Begland as Richmond District Court judge was no different.[2]

Begland became a General District Court judge on Thursday after the Richmond Circuit Court appointed him as Virginia’s first openly gay judge.[3]

When Begland’s nomination was in the Virginia House of Delegates, Del. Marshall was the leading opponent of Begland’s appointment, labeling the former Richmond attorney a “homosexual activist”[4].

In an email sent to Gov. McDonnell and released to the news media on Friday however, Marshall sounded a different note. Marshall wrote, “Your support of this judicial appointment by circuit judges means you hold the appointed judiciary to be a branch of Virginia’s government superior to the branch elected by the people, the General Assembly.”

While McDonnell has already made his distaste for the democratic process known by previous actions[5], Marshall’s email attempts to mask the real reasons why he so ardently opposes Begland’s appointment to the bench, a reason which Marshall already noted himself during the regular session of the General Assembly. That is, Marshall’s fundamental reason for opposing Begland’s appointment is because he is openly homosexual.

Furthermore, it does not follow that an openly gay judge will be a “homosexual activist” judge anymore than it follows that a Virginia politician will uphold the best interests of all Virginians.

Individuals and politicians alike who think like Del. Marshall need to take a look at their calendars and recognize what year this is. It’s a year of tolerance and compassion, not intolerance and bigotry.

Begland’s appointment hopefully marks a new chapter in the history of Virginia, one of tolerance and openness to different ways of living. When I look at Virginia’s history, I see more negatives than positives. 

But we can turn a new corner for the better now, and with Begland’s appointment, maybe the first step has been taken in this direction.

No comments:

Post a Comment